Monday, October 31, 2005
Friday, October 14, 2005
Thursday, October 13, 2005
October Weather
My god, the weather's been lovely this October. I even ate lunch in the park today, though I'd rather have been surfing Blacks.
Monday, October 10, 2005
Thursday, October 06, 2005
Letter to Senator Feinstein
Dear Senator Feinstein,
I would feel forever vindicated for all the times I voted for you (even despite your voting record on digitial property rights issues) if, during the coming hearings on the President's Supreme Court nominee, you raised something like the following questions:
1. Do you think the example of Portugal offers any lessons for lawmakers and law-interpreters addressing the issue of abortion? (Overview the current state of abortion rights in Portugal if she pleads ignorance -- see http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4291696.stm for recent BBC article on topic)
2. Are you familiar with the controversy over the teaching of evolution in high school biology classes? In your judgement, is there a reasonable basis for not making evolutionary theory the foundation of biology and the teaching of biology? Do you find that the evidence supports the claim that evolution explains the historical development of human beings?
Please do not add me to any mailing lists.
Regards,
Tom Atwell
I would feel forever vindicated for all the times I voted for you (even despite your voting record on digitial property rights issues) if, during the coming hearings on the President's Supreme Court nominee, you raised something like the following questions:
1. Do you think the example of Portugal offers any lessons for lawmakers and law-interpreters addressing the issue of abortion? (Overview the current state of abortion rights in Portugal if she pleads ignorance -- see http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4291696.stm for recent BBC article on topic)
2. Are you familiar with the controversy over the teaching of evolution in high school biology classes? In your judgement, is there a reasonable basis for not making evolutionary theory the foundation of biology and the teaching of biology? Do you find that the evidence supports the claim that evolution explains the historical development of human beings?
Please do not add me to any mailing lists.
Regards,
Tom Atwell
My god, she has an amateurish website. I wonder if that's deliberate.
Tuesday, October 04, 2005
Grey and Green Goo
I'm familiar with the name Ray Kurzweil thanks to some reading I've done on artificial intelligence. Provocative thread about him on slashdot yesterday. Found this buried in the comments:
Good example. Intriguing discussion.
I'm a grey goo skeptic as well, but only because I think it is unlikely for practical reasons, not impossible for theoretical reasons. The comparison of Grey Goo with naturally evolved microbes ("Green Goo") misses the point that the man- (or machine-) designed nanobots can explore areas of design space that are blocked to natural selection, perhaps by being hidden behind local minima in the fitness landscape.
A well known example of such a feature (albeit on the macro device scale) is an eye with telescopic vision: an engineer can produce this feature trivially by placing one lense behind another and allowing the distance between them to vary. However, in spite of being independently evolved in the animal kingdom as many as a dozen times, no known animal eye has managed to find its way to this two-lense arrangement. Neither has any gradient-descent-constrained simulation of eye evolution managed to achieve this configuration (to the best of my admittedly-amateur knowledge).
(For those unfamiliar with the "local minimum" problem, it's this: a creature with, say, a misshapen doubled-up lense would be outcompeted by its already-extant fully-sighted peers long before its hypothetical future descendants could have time to happen upon the further refinements needed to implement the long-term-superior telescoping design.)
In the nano realm, there may well be enough yet-unknown technological tricks left in the bag to make sunlight-powered dirt-eating replicators a theoretical possibility.
But I wouldn't lose any sleep over the possibility, either.
-- Saucepan
A well known example of such a feature (albeit on the macro device scale) is an eye with telescopic vision: an engineer can produce this feature trivially by placing one lense behind another and allowing the distance between them to vary. However, in spite of being independently evolved in the animal kingdom as many as a dozen times, no known animal eye has managed to find its way to this two-lense arrangement. Neither has any gradient-descent-constrained simulation of eye evolution managed to achieve this configuration (to the best of my admittedly-amateur knowledge).
(For those unfamiliar with the "local minimum" problem, it's this: a creature with, say, a misshapen doubled-up lense would be outcompeted by its already-extant fully-sighted peers long before its hypothetical future descendants could have time to happen upon the further refinements needed to implement the long-term-superior telescoping design.)
In the nano realm, there may well be enough yet-unknown technological tricks left in the bag to make sunlight-powered dirt-eating replicators a theoretical possibility.
But I wouldn't lose any sleep over the possibility, either.
-- Saucepan
Good example. Intriguing discussion.